Background

The Eternit proceedings in Italy are legally exceptionally complex and have extended over two decades. The following overview explains, in factual terms, what they are about, which proceedings are being conducted and which rule-of-law issues lie at their core.

Status: 9 November 2026

On the rule-of-law principles in the Eternit proceedings

The human suffering of asbestos victims is undisputed. The legal question in the Eternit proceedings is whether the health consequences of historical industrial activities can be attributed to a single individual under criminal law.

Stephan Schmidheiny’s defence states that fundamental rule-of-law guarantees are a prerequisite for any criminal judgment, including in proceedings of great public sensitivity: the right to a fair trial, the right to an effective defence, the presumption of innocence and the principle of equality of arms (Art. 6 ECHR), as well as the prohibition of being prosecuted or punished twice (ne bis in idem, Art. 4 of Protocol No. 7 to the ECHR; Art. 50 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU).

The Eternit proceedings in Italy

An overview of the exceptionally complex proceedings against the Swiss entrepreneur and philanthropist Stephan Schmidheiny, which have been ongoing for more than 20 years.

What it is about

What are the Eternit proceedings in Italy about?

The Eternit proceedings concern the health consequences of decades of asbestos processing in Italy, which was banned in 1992. Asbestos can cause cancers that usually appear only decades after exposure. The human suffering is undisputed. Legally, however, the central question is whether an individual entrepreneur can be held criminally responsible for the health consequences of historical industrial activities. Moreover, where a person was exposed over a long period during which several managers successively ran the plant or owned it as shareholders, the crucial question is whether it can be established at all which of them is responsible.

Why are the Eternit proceedings regarded as an international special case?

Italy is the only country that to this day attributes the long-term health consequences of asbestos processing to individual natural persons under criminal law, even when the relevant events lie decades in the past and no operational role existed. This is at odds with fundamental principles of criminal law, in particular the requirement to attribute specific acts and causal chains to an individual. Internationally, the consequences of asbestos are mostly dealt with under civil or social-security law or through compensation funds.

Does asbestos exposure stem from Eternit alone?

No. For a long time asbestos was regarded as a kind of miracle fibre, because it is particularly durable, heat-resistant and a good insulator. It was therefore widely used worldwide in construction, industry and consumer goods for much of the 20th century.

Eternit I and Eternit bis

What was “Eternit I” and how did the proceedings end?

The first proceedings (investigations from 2001, Stephan Schmidheiny entered in the register of persons under investigation in 2004, indictment in 2009, ruling of the Court of Cassation in November 2014) did not charge classic homicide offences, but “causing an environmental disaster”. They assessed the same conduct of Stephan Schmidheiny with which he was later charged again in Eternit bis. The deaths – including 186 of those later charged in Eternit bis – were recorded as consequences of the disaster, not as individual homicides with an examination of individual causation. In November 2014 the Corte Suprema di Cassazione quashed the convictions of the lower courts without referral: the alleged offence had ended at the latest with the closure of the plants in 1986 and was therefore already time-barred before the first-instance judgment. The trial should therefore never have been held. With the expiry of the limitation period, all civil claims also lapsed. In his closing address, the Prosecutor General at the Supreme Court, Francesco Iacoviello, had stressed that between law and justice the judge must choose the law.

What are the Eternit bis proceedings?

After Eternit I ended, the Turin Public Prosecutor’s Office opened new proceedings in 2015 (Eternit bis), this time for the intentional homicide of individual persons. They concern the Eternit factories in Casale Monferrato, Cavagnolo, Naples and Rubiera. For procedural reasons they are conducted separately, although in the defence’s view they are based on the same conduct.

Why were the charges originally brought for intentional homicide – and what changed?

The prosecution originally brought charges of intentional homicide. Under Italian law this offence is not subject to a limitation period. The aim was to make criminal prosecution possible despite the long time that had elapsed since the relevant events.

In 2016 the Turin preliminary hearing judge ruled out intent and reclassified the charges as negligent homicide. In 2018 the Supreme Court confirmed this assessment as legally correct and well reasoned (judgment no. 21732/2018). Neither awareness of risks nor the pursuit of business profit is sufficient to establish intent in the criminal-law sense. In the Naples (2022) and Casale Monferrato (2023) proceedings, too, the courts ruled out intent. Under Italian law negligent homicide is subject to a limitation period.

Why is the principle of “ne bis in idem” relevant?

The defence argues that the Eternit bis proceedings are based on the same conduct as Eternit I. Under European human rights standards, no one may be prosecuted more than once for essentially identical facts – regardless of the legal label given to the charge. On a referral in the proceedings against Stephan Schmidheiny, the Italian Constitutional Court in 2016 declared the Code of Criminal Procedure partly unconstitutional on this point (judgment no. 200/2016) and held that the same offence exists only where conduct, event and causal link coincide. On this basis the courts have so far ruled out ne bis in idem between Eternit I and Eternit bis, because the event did not coincide: the deaths of workers and residents are treated as elements of the offence only in Eternit bis, where Stephan Schmidheiny is charged with homicide. In September 2025, however, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that the same conduct is sufficient for ne bis in idem to apply. As the conduct of Stephan Schmidheiny in Eternit I and in Eternit bis is the same, in the defence’s view all the conditions for applying the principle are met. The defence raised the question again in the Casale Monferrato proceedings. The hearing before the Corte Suprema di Cassazione takes place on 10 November 2026.

Causation and case law

What is the central legal problem in Eternit bis?

The core problem is individual causation. Criminal responsibility requires proof, with sufficient certainty, that specific acts of a particular person caused the death of a particular person (“beyond reasonable doubt”). A generalised or purely statistical approach is not enough. In the defence’s view, this proof cannot be provided for asbestos-related diseases because of long latency periods, multiple sources of exposure and disease histories that cannot be medically reconstructed.

Are there other criminal proceedings in Italy concerning asbestos?

Over the past decades, numerous criminal proceedings concerning asbestos exposure have been conducted in Italy, among others against former executives of FIAT, Olivetti, Pirelli, RAI, the shipbuilding industry (Fincantieri), the railways and the steel and energy industries. Settled case law now requires specific individual proof of causation between the conduct of a particular person and the death or illness of a particular victim. Where this could not be proven beyond doubt, there have been no final convictions in recent years.

How has the Corte Suprema di Cassazione ruled in the Eternit bis proceedings so far?

The Supreme Court has quashed convictions of Stephan Schmidheiny three times because the lower courts had not provided sound reasons for the individual causal link: in the Cavagnolo proceedings in May 2024 and March 2025, and in the Naples proceedings in February 2025 (judgment no. 15220/2025). In Naples, the referral back led in October 2026 to the proceedings being discontinued as time-barred.

In Rubiera, the preliminary investigations judge in Reggio Emilia had already discontinued the proceedings in January 2021 – at the request of the prosecution itself, because it could not be established which conduct had caused the illnesses. In this context the Supreme Court has repeatedly stressed that statistical probabilities must not replace individual criminal guilt.

What role do scientific studies play?

Because the events lie decades in the past, evidence is missing and witnesses have died or are no longer fit to testify, the courts rely on epidemiological and experimental studies. Such studies can show general correlations. In the defence’s view, however, they do not replace the proof of a specific cause in the individual case required under criminal law.

What is the ‘Farahmand study’, and what role does it play in the Casale Monferrato proceedings?

The study (Farahmand et al., ‘Asbestos accelerates disease onset in a genetic model of malignant pleural mesothelioma’, Frontiers in Toxicology) was published on 27 June 2023, three weeks after the first-instance judgment in the Casale Monferrato case. The prosecution introduced it only at the appeal stage. In April 2025 the Turin appeal court made it a cornerstone of its reasoning.

Only the period 1976–1986 is attributed to Stephan Schmidheiny, yet many of those affected had been exposed decades earlier. A conviction therefore requires proof, in each individual case, that exposure during that period specifically caused or accelerated the death. In the Rubiera proceedings the prosecution considered such proof impossible, and in the Naples proceedings the Supreme Court expressly required it.

The Turin appeal court bridged this gap with the study. It declared the acceleration effect ‘scientifically proven’ and a ‘universal law’ applying in every single case. At the same time, it conceded that no signs of acceleration can be found in individual cases.

In the defence’s view, the study does not support this conclusion:

  • It is a single laboratory experiment involving a total of 26 mice, 17 treated with asbestos and 9 not.
  • The animals were genetically modified so that they develop mesothelioma even without asbestos.
  • The study compared exposed with unexposed animals – not more heavily with less heavily exposed animals, which is what the proceedings would require. All treated mice received a single, identical dose.
  • At least two exposed mice lived longer than several unexposed ones. Even in the experiment, therefore, not every case was accelerated.


In the defence’s view, an average derived from a small group of animals cannot replace proof of causation for 91 people with very different exposure histories. The defence has challenged this before the Supreme Court.

Status of the proceedings

What is the status of the Eternit bis proceedings?

Casale Monferrato: In June 2023 the Novara Court of Assizes sentenced Stephan Schmidheiny to 12 years’ imprisonment for the negligent homicide of 147 people. In April 2025 the Turin Court of Appeal reduced the conviction to 91 people (7 workers and 84 local residents) and the sentence to 9 years and 6 months; it acquitted in 29 cases, and 27 cases were time-barred. In February 2026 the Supreme Court quashed this judgment on formal grounds because it had not been served in a language the defendant understands. After the translation was served, the defence lodged a new appeal on 15 May 2026. The hearing before the Corte Suprema di Cassazione takes place on 10 November 2026.

Naples-Bagnoli: On 27 October 2026, after the referral back by the Supreme Court, the Naples Court of Appeal discontinued the proceedings as time-barred. It ruled on the civil claims according to civil-law standards; no criminal guilt has thus been established. The defence is challenging the judgment before the Supreme Court and is seeking an acquittal on the merits.

Cavagnolo: The Supreme Court has twice quashed the conviction (May 2024 and March 2025), both times because the reasoning on causation was deficient. In the defence’s view, the case is time-barred. The Turin Court of Appeal will hear it on 3 December 2026.

Rubiera: Discontinued in 2021 at the request of the prosecution.

What are the proceedings concerning Casale Monferrato about?

The proceedings concern criminal responsibility for asbestos-related deaths of workers and local residents of the Eternit factory in Casale Monferrato. The central issue is individual causation, i.e. whether specific conduct actually caused the death of individual persons.

The situation in Casale is special in that, in addition to industrial production, asbestos-containing production residues (“polverino”) were used for decades in public and private spaces. This resulted in numerous sources of exposure that are difficult to separate. The supply of such residues to third parties was prohibited in 1974 under the leadership of the Swiss Eternit Group.

Who are the 91 people in the Casale Monferrato proceedings, and what was their connection to the factory?

The original indictment concerned the deaths of 392 people. In June 2023 the Novara Court of Assizes, at first instance, convicted Stephan Schmidheiny in respect of 147 deaths. In 46 cases it acquitted him because the offence had not been proven (‘il fatto non sussiste’), and 199 cases were time-barred. The grounds for these acquittals ranged from an uncertain diagnosis or a different cause of death to places of residence far outside Casale, other occupational sources of asbestos, or exposure that predated 1976.

In April 2025 the Turin Court of Appeal reduced the conviction to 91 deaths. In a further 29 cases it acquitted him because the offence had not been proven (‘il fatto non sussiste’), and 27 cases had meanwhile become time-barred. The conviction thus covers fewer than a quarter of the 392 deaths originally charged. In a total of 75 cases, the courts themselves found that a criminal causal link had not been proven.

The remaining 91 people do not form a uniform group. Only 7 were former workers at the factory, with very different jobs and periods of employment. The other 84 were local residents who never worked at the factory. For them, the court assumed environmental or indirect exposure to asbestos, for example through a family member’s work clothes.

For the residents, the Court of Appeal relied essentially on a single individual criterion: that they lived within two kilometres of the factory between 1976 and 1986. Yet the judgment itself shows how different the individual life histories are:

  • Almost all had already been exposed in Casale for decades before 1976.
  • For several of them, the time spent living within two kilometres between 1976 and 1986 was five years or less.
  • For at least 17 people, the judgment mentions other sources of asbestos, such as their own occupational exposure.
  • Asbestos-containing production waste (‘polverino’) was spread throughout the town for decades.

In the defence’s view, for none of these people can it be proven with the certainty required in criminal law that exposure in the years 1976–1986 specifically caused the illness. These are the same doubts that have already led to acquittals in other cases.

What is the situation in Casale Monferrato today?

Casale Monferrato is regarded as one of the most comprehensively remediated former asbestos areas in Italy. According to the city administration, 217 of the 227 identified polverino sites have been fully remediated; work on the remaining sites is under way or specifically scheduled.

What were the proceedings concerning the Eternit factory in Naples-Bagnoli about?

The original charge was the intentional homicide of six former employees and two local residents. In 2022 the court of first instance ruled out intent, acquitted in one case and discontinued six cases as time-barred. In one case it convicted of negligent homicide; the Court of Appeal upheld this in 2024. In February 2025 the Supreme Court quashed this conviction in its entirety: the lower court should not have inferred from the duration and intensity of exposure that the course of the disease had been accelerated in the specific case (judgment no. 15220/2025). After the referral back, the Naples Court of Appeal discontinued the proceedings on 27 October 2026 as time-barred.

What are the proceedings concerning the Eternit factory in Cavagnolo about?

The plant in Cavagnolo (Piedmont) closed in 1982. In May 2019 the Turin court (Tribunale di Torino) sentenced Stephan Schmidheiny to four years’ imprisonment for negligent homicide in two cases. In February 2023 the Turin Court of Appeal upheld the conviction in respect of one former worker only, with a suspended sentence of one year and eight months. It acquitted him of the negligent homicide of a person living near the plant. The worker had been employed at the plant since 1955, more than twenty years before the period from June 1976 attributed to Stephan Schmidheiny.

Another Turin court had reached the opposite conclusion on the same death in 2015 and acquitted former local managers of the plant. Thanks to technical upgrades, fibre exposure at the plant had fallen sharply from the mid-1970s, and no contribution of the later, much lower exposure to the illness could be proven.

In May 2024 the Supreme Court quashed the conviction because the causal link had not been soundly reasoned (judgment no. 30615/2024). The Turin Court of Appeal convicted Stephan Schmidheiny again in December 2024. In March 2025 the Supreme Court quashed that judgment too; the Prosecutor General’s Office had itself argued for it to be set aside. In the defence’s view, the case has been time-barred since April 2025. The Turin Court of Appeal will hear the case on 3 December 2026. The defence is seeking an acquittal on the merits, or at least a discontinuation on grounds of limitation.

What were the proceedings concerning the Eternit factory in Rubiera about?

The proceedings arose from a complaint filed by the municipality of Rubiera (Emilia-Romagna) and were opened in 2015 against Stephan Schmidheiny and a former managing director of Eternit SpA. The charge was negligent homicide of 52 people – former workers, people who spent a great deal of time at the plant, and local residents.

The Rubiera factory had produced asbestos-cement sheets since 1961 and belonged to the company ICAR until 1980. It passed to Eternit SpA only in June 1980. The prosecution therefore limited Stephan Schmidheiny’s possible responsibility to the period from June 1980 the court-supervised administration in December 1984 – roughly four and a half years.

Why were the Rubiera proceedings discontinued?

In 2020 the Public Prosecutor’s Office in Reggio Emilia, relying on the reports of its own experts, concluded that criminal responsibility could not be established:

  • The great majority of the deceased had worked at the factory before it came to Eternit, in some cases decades earlier.
  • For several people, the prosecution’s own expert ruled out a link with work at the factory because of the short period of employment or the latency period. Some had never worked there at all.
  • Heavy asbestos exposure dated from the 1960s and 1970s, under earlier managers who have since died.
  • Once a cancer has been triggered, later exposure no longer affects its course. On current knowledge, it is impossible to determine when that point was reached. Nor is there any established scientific law that longer exposure accelerates the disease (the so-called ‘acceleration effect’). It was therefore impossible to establish whether exposure in 1980–1984 specifically had caused the deaths.
  • Among local residents, no increased incidence of pleural tumours could be shown in Rubiera.

In the prosecution’s view, a trial would not change this. In January 2021 the preliminary investigations judge in Reggio Emilia discontinued the proceedings as requested.

Rule-of-law questions

What does the statute of limitations mean – and is it a loophole?

The statute of limitations is a fundamental institution of the rule of law. It ensures that criminal proceedings do not remain open indefinitely, because as time passes evidence is lost, witnesses die, and an effective defence becomes almost impossible. Under Italian law, an acquittal on the merits takes precedence over the statute of limitations; the defence therefore seeks an acquittal on the merits in all proceedings.

Anyone who has not been finally convicted may not be treated as guilty by the authorities, even where proceedings end because the limitation period has expired. The European Court of Human Rights has held this on several occasions.

Why is the European Convention on Human Rights relevant?

Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights guarantees the right to a fair trial. It requires an independent and impartial tribunal established by law, a decision within a reasonable time, equality of arms between the parties and comprehensive rights of the defence. It also enshrines the presumption of innocence. The defence contends that several aspects of the proceedings violate this right, and that the Eternit bis proceedings breach the prohibition of double prosecution (Article 4 of Protocol No. 7 to the ECHR, Article 50 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union).

What role do the media and public pressure play?

The Eternit proceedings have been under strong media and emotional pressure for years. In regions such as Monferrato in Piedmont they are part of local collective memory. Court decisions there are often judged normatively (“just” or “unjust”) rather than as the result of an examination of evidence under the rule of law. This distinction is crucial, because criminal courts are bound by legal standards of proof, not by subjective notions of justice.

Responsibility towards those affected

Are there other ways of coming to terms with the past in Italy?

Yes. An important example is Eternit Siciliana in Syracuse. There, former workers and their families chose a path of reconciliation and practical help and in 2008 concluded a civil-law agreement with Becon AG, acting on behalf of Stephan Schmidheiny. A social fund was set up which has since provided financial support to those affected and financed medical care and social infrastructure.

What is the humanitarian programme in Casale Monferrato?

In Casale Monferrato a voluntary humanitarian financial assistance programme run by Becon AG on behalf of Stephan Schmidheiny has existed since 2008. As an expression of personal solidarity, he expressly extended it in 2009 to residents (or their heirs) who have contracted mesothelioma and lived in Casale during the so-called “Swiss period” (1976–1986). In Italy, more than 2,000 people have so far received payments. Stephan Schmidheiny also supports medical research into the treatment of mesothelioma, currently through a three-year programme of around EUR 2.4 million coordinated with the asbestos victims’ association AFEVA. The programmes are voluntary and independent of the criminal proceedings.

Stephan Schmidheiny’s role in Italy

What role did Stephan Schmidheiny have at Eternit SpA in Italy?

Through the Swiss Eternit Group, Stephan Schmidheiny was a shareholder, not an operational manager of the Italian plants. He had no management, technical or safety function, was not involved in day-to-day operations and was not a member of the board of the Italian Eternit SpA. The courts derive from his position at the head of the Swiss Eternit Group a duty of care (“posizione di garanzia”) for safety in the Italian plants.

How did Stephan Schmidheiny come to Eternit?

He joined the family business in 1974 and took over overall management of the Swiss Eternit Group in 1976. Stephan Schmidheiny was neither a founder of the asbestos industry nor the initiator of asbestos use. Rather, he is regarded as one of the early pioneers of the exit from asbestos: as early as the 1970s he pushed investment in occupational safety, in 1976 he launched an innovation programme for asbestos-free products, and in 1981 he announced the exit from asbestos processing.

What was known about the risks in 1976 – and how did Stephan Schmidheiny respond?

The risks of asbestos were openly addressed in 1976, including by Stephan Schmidheiny at a conference of the Eternit Group in Neuss. The international debate of the 1970s, however, was not one of prohibition: states, authorities and international organisations assumed that the risks could be controlled through strict protective measures (“safe use”). Shortly after he took office, programmes to reduce dust and improve occupational safety were launched within the group and the development of asbestos-free products was driven forward. The historical question is not whether risks were known, but how they were responded to.

Which period concerns Stephan Schmidheiny specifically?

The proceedings deal with the period from 1976 to 1986, during which Stephan Schmidheiny headed the Swiss Eternit Group. From Eternit SpA’s application for court-supervised administration at the end of 1984, the Swiss group no longer had any decisive influence; Eternit SpA went bankrupt in 1986.

Who was responsible before 1976?

Eternit SpA was founded in 1906 and, until its bankruptcy in 1986, was a listed company with numerous shareholders. Before 1976, ownership and operational responsibility lay with earlier generations of owners and the management of the time. The Swiss Eternit Group became the main shareholder in 1973 and gradually increased its stake to a majority in the course of capital increases needed to stabilise the company. Before that, various shareholder groups held significant stakes, including the Belgian Eternit Group. A binding limit value for asbestos fibres was introduced in Italy only in 1991, and the ban followed in 1992 – years after the plants had closed.

What happened between 1976 and 1986?

During this phase, substantial investments in occupational safety and emission reduction were also made in the Italian Eternit plants. According to findings that the Supreme Court confirmed as conclusive in 2018, methods for measuring fibre concentration and technical innovations that actually reduced exposure were introduced in Italy under the leadership of the Swiss Eternit Group. In addition, monitoring bodies were set up and the supply of production waste (“polverino”) to third parties was prohibited. By 1984 most Swiss Eternit products were asbestos-free – six years before Switzerland’s asbestos ban of 1990.

Were there investments in safety – and was capital withdrawn from Italy?

Between 1976 and the court-supervised administration at the end of 1984, the Italian Eternit companies invested around 30 billion Italian lire in their plants, including in dust extraction, the switch to wet processes and the development of asbestos-free substitute fibres. For the years 1973 to 1984 the figure is around 33 billion lire. This figure was also adopted by the courts. This was possible only because the Swiss group provided funds of around 84 billion lire during this period, including bank guarantees called in, although the Italian companies were continuously making losses. At most around 4 billion lire flowed back to Switzerland in dividends and licence fees. As most of the records were lost in a flood, individual safety expenditure can no longer be fully reconstructed.

What happened from 1986 onwards?

In 1986 the Italian Eternit SpA went bankrupt. The plants were placed under state insolvency administration. From that point on, the Swiss Eternit Group no longer had any legal or de facto authority over operations, closure, remediation or disposal.

Why is this chronology decisive?

The disease histories examined involve exposures with latency periods of several decades and multiple sources, which lie long before and long after the period during which Stephan Schmidheiny bore responsibility for the Swiss Eternit Group.