This section contains references to the relevant court decisions and further sources. They allow a verifiable, in-depth examination of the proceedings and their background.
Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Judgment No. 7941/2015 – Eternit I (decided on 19 November 2014)
Conviction overturned: the “disaster” charged was already time-barred before the first-instance judgment; the civil claims lapsed.
Full text (Osservatorio Olympus, University of Urbino)
Corte costituzionale, Judgment No. 200/2016 (July 2016)
Ne bis in idem: what is decisive is the historical facts, not their legal classification. On a referral from the proceedings against Stephan Schmidheiny.
Full text (Corte costituzionale)
Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Judgment No. 21732/2018 – Eternit bis
Confirmation: no intent; the charges are to be assessed as negligent homicide.
Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Judgment No. 30615/2024 – Cavagnolo (May 2024)
Conviction overturned and case remanded owing to deficient reasoning on causation.
Full text, anonymised (Osservatorio Olympus)
Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Judgment No. 15220/2025 – Naples (February 2025)
Conviction overturned and case remanded: an acceleration of the course of the disease in the individual case may not be inferred from the duration and intensity of exposure.
Full text (Osservatorio Olympus)
Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Judgment No. 15486/2025 – Cavagnolo (March 2025)
Second reversal of the conviction; the Office of the Prosecutor General itself argued for annulment.
Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Judgment No. 8176/2026 – Casale Monferrato (February 2026)
Set aside on formal grounds (missing translation of the judgment).
Full text, anonymised
Tribunale di Torino, judgment of 4 November 2015 – Cavagnolo
Acquittal of former local managers of the plant, including in respect of the death that later became the subject of the proceedings against Stephan Schmidheiny.
Preliminary Investigations Judge (GIP), Tribunale di Reggio Emilia – Rubiera proceedings, 4 January 2021
Dismissal of the criminal proceedings. The court adopts the prosecution’s reasoning in full: individual causation cannot be proven, and earlier exposures are equally valid alternative causes.
Decree (anonymised)
Public Prosecutor’s Office of Reggio Emilia, application for dismissal of 13 October 2020 – Rubiera
Application for discontinuation because it could not be established which conduct was causally decisive for the disease.
Request (anonymised)
Sources
Wolfgang E. Höper, “Asbest in der Moderne. Industrielle Produktion, Verarbeitung, Verbot, Substitution und Entsorgung”, 2008 (in German)
Includes a chapter entitled “Die Innovation des Stephan Schmidheiny – das Wagnis der vollständigen Substitution von Asbest” (Stephan Schmidheiny’s innovation – the bold step of completely substituting asbestos).
Waxmann Verlag
Werner Catrina, “Der Eternit-Report”, 1985 (in German)
Background literature on the company’s history.