This section contains the press releases on the Eternit proceedings in Italy, with the most recent first. Each release reflects the situation at the time of publication. The “Current status” section is updated whenever there are new developments. An overview of the proceedings and the relevant court decisions can be found under “Background” and “Documents”. Media enquiries can be submitted via “Contact”.
10 November 2026
For the fourth time: Italy’s Supreme Court quashes an Eternit judgment against Stephan Schmidheiny
The April 2025 judgment on Casale Monferrato is also flawed – the case will be reassessed
On 10 November 2026, Italy’s Supreme Court, the Corte Suprema di Cassazione, quashed the judgment of the Turin Court of Appeal of 17 April 2025 against Swiss entrepreneur Stephan Schmidheiny and referred the case back to Turin for reassessment. The conviction for the negligent homicide of 91 people and the sentence of 9 years and 6 months’ imprisonment have thus been set aside. In 26 cases the court also found that the limitation period has since expired.
The written reasons will be available in the coming weeks. In its appeal to the Court of Cassation, the defence argued in particular that the Turin judgment fails to establish causation in the individual case. What would have to be proven is that it was specifically the asbestos exposure in the years 1976 to 1986, which are attributed to Stephan Schmidheiny, that triggered the illness of each individual person or accelerated its course. For such an acceleration, the Turin court relied on a laboratory study involving 26 genetically modified mice. A study of this kind cannot replace proof in the individual case. In the proceedings concerning the Eternit factories in Cavagnolo (May 2024 and March 2025) and Naples (February 2025), the Supreme Court had already quashed convictions because individual causation had not been proven. Since the first indictment in 2009, no conviction of Stephan Schmidheiny by a lower court has therefore been upheld by the Supreme Court.
Decades of asbestos use have led to a societal tragedy in Casale Monferrato that continues to claim lives to this day. The defence’s sympathy goes to all those affected and to their families. Stephan Schmidheiny has never turned away from this: independently of the criminal proceedings, he has voluntarily supported those affected in Italy since 2008 – more than 2,000 people have received financial assistance. He also contributes financially in Italy to research into the treatment of mesothelioma, the cancer caused by asbestos. Solidarity with those affected and individual criminal guilt must be clearly distinguished. Guilt must be proven in the individual case in accordance with the rule of law.
As most recently in Naples, the question of the statute of limitations will also arise in the further proceedings. The statute of limitations is not a loophole but a cornerstone of the rule of law: it protects people from being judged decades after the events without reliable evidence. Stephan Schmidheiny has faced criminal prosecution in Italy for more than twenty years. In the new proceedings, too, the defence will seek an acquittal on the merits.
27 October 2026
Eternit Naples: proceedings against Stephan Schmidheiny discontinued
Defence to seek an acquittal on the merits before the Supreme Court
The Naples Court of Assizes of Appeal (Corte d’Assise d’Appello) today discontinued the Eternit bis proceedings against Swiss entrepreneur Stephan Schmidheiny concerning the former factory in Naples-Bagnoli. The charge of negligent homicide of a former worker has been time-barred. Despite the limitation period having expired, the court was required to rule on the civil claims brought in the criminal proceedings; applying civil-law standards, it partially upheld them and awarded the civil parties their legal costs. No criminal guilt has thus been established. The first of the three ongoing Eternit bis proceedings therefore ends without a criminal conviction – eleven years after the Turin Public Prosecutor’s Office opened them. A conviction is thus ruled out. The defence will nevertheless appeal to Italy’s Supreme Court – against both the civil-law ruling and the discontinuation on grounds of limitation – in order to obtain an acquittal on the merits.
Four rounds of proceedings – no criminal proof of causation
The proceedings concerning the Eternit factory in Naples – separated from the Turin Eternit bis case in 2016 – began in 2019 with an indictment for the intentional homicide of eight people. In April 2022 the court of first instance ruled out intent, acquitted in one case, discontinued six cases as time-barred and convicted solely of the negligent homicide of one worker. The Court of Appeal upheld this in June 2024. The deceased worker had worked at the plant from 1954 to 1985, around twenty years of it before 1976 – the year from which the prosecution holds Stephan Schmidheiny responsible as head of the Swiss Eternit Group. In February 2025 Italy’s Supreme Court, the Corte Suprema di Cassazione, quashed the judgment: the claim that asbestos exposure from 1976 onwards had accelerated the disease was a statistical statement, not proof in the individual case.
The second appeal proceedings, under way since December 2025, also failed to provide precisely this criminal-law proof. At the hearing on 23 June 2026 the prosecution’s medical expert acknowledged that no records demonstrate such an acceleration and that epidemiological probability statements cannot simply be transferred to the individual case. The court then closed the taking of evidence without hearing the defence expert.
The defence had applied for an acquittal on the merits; instead, the court found that the limitation period had expired. In the defence’s view, the statements of the prosecution’s expert should have led to an acquittal on the merits, which under Italian law takes precedence over the statute of limitations. Once the written reasons are available, the defence will therefore challenge the judgment before the Court of Cassation – both the discontinuation on grounds of limitation and the civil-law ruling. No criminal conviction of Stephan Schmidheiny remains in place.
The statute of limitations is not a loophole
The statute of limitations is a fundamental institution of the rule of law. It ensures that criminal proceedings do not remain open indefinitely, because as time passes evidence is lost, witnesses die, and an effective defence becomes almost impossible. Anyone now claiming that Stephan Schmidheiny escaped conviction only because of the statute of limitations ignores the facts: for more than twenty years, the prosecuting authorities have failed in every one of the Eternit proceedings to establish an individual causal link with final effect. Three times the Supreme Court has quashed convictions for precisely this reason – twice in the Cavagnolo proceedings (2024, 2025) and once in Naples (2025). In Naples, too, the additional taking of evidence did not provide this criminal-law proof. It was not the statute of limitations that prevented a criminal conviction, but the absence of criminal-law proof. The fact that the court assessed the civil claims under the less stringent standards of civil law does not change this.
Asbestos is a societal tragedy – not individual guilt
The consequences of decades of industrial asbestos use are tragic. The defence’s sympathy goes to the relatives of the deceased and to all those affected. Independently of the criminal proceedings, Stephan Schmidheiny has supported voluntary humanitarian programmes for those affected in Italy since 2008. In the 20th century asbestos was a material used worldwide, and in Italy it was permitted until 1992. Its consequences are a legacy of society as a whole. Criminal law cannot come to terms with this history by declaring a single individual guilty decades later. Guilt must be proven individually. Blanket attributions of risk, statistical models or retrospective assessments cannot replace such proof.
Stephan Schmidheiny took over responsibility for the Swiss Eternit Group in 1976, introduced measures to reduce fibre exposure and, as a pioneer, led the company out of asbestos processing. That he has faced criminal prosecution for more than twenty years shows an overreach of criminal law – and is a burden that no judgment can outweigh.
The written reasons will follow within the statutory time limit.
Current status: Once the written reasons are available, the defence will appeal to the Court of Cassation – against both the discontinuation on grounds of limitation and the civil-law ruling. Its aim is an acquittal on the merits. The judgment is not yet final.
11 February 2026
Italy’s highest court remands the judgment on the Eternit factory in Casale Monferrato on formal grounds
A missing translation violates the right of defence.
On 11 February 2026, the Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Italy’s highest court, remanded the judgment in the Eternit bis proceedings concerning the former Eternit factory in Casale Monferrato to the lower court on formal grounds. The court found that the second-instance judgment of 17 April 2025 had not been served on the defendant, Stephan Schmidheiny, in a language he understands.
Under Italian procedural law, this violates the right of defence and renders the judgment null as a document. The case has therefore been remanded to the lower court solely to remedy this formal defect. The Turin Court of Appeal must translate the existing judgment into German and serve it on the defendant and his defence counsel. The parties will then again have the opportunity to appeal to Italy’s highest court. The decision does not involve any assessment by the highest court of the substantive questions of guilt or causation. As a result of the decision, the sentence of 9 years and 6 months’ imprisonment is not final.
The defence states that compliance with fundamental rule-of-law guarantees – in particular the right to a fair trial and to an effective defence – is a prerequisite for any criminal judgment, including in proceedings of great public sensitivity.
Current status: The German translation of the judgment was served on Stephan Schmidheiny in early April 2026. The defence filed a new appeal on 15 May 2026. The hearing before the Corte Suprema di Cassazione is scheduled for 10 November 2026.
22 March 2025
Italy’s highest court overturns conviction in the Eternit proceedings concerning Cavagnolo
Third consecutive reversal of a second-instance conviction – the Cavagnolo case becomes time-barred in April 2025.
On 21 March 2025, the Corte Suprema di Cassazione overturned Stephan Schmidheiny’s second-instance conviction in the Eternit bis proceedings concerning the former factory in Cavagnolo and remanded the case to the lower court owing to flaws in the assessment of the evidence. Notably, the Office of the Prosecutor General itself argued for annulment at the hearing, because the causal link had once again not been soundly established in the second appeal proceedings.
In December 2024 – after a first judgment that the highest court had likewise overturned in May 2024 – the Turin Court of Appeal had again convicted Stephan Schmidheiny of the negligent homicide of a former worker and sentenced him to a suspended prison term of one year and eight months. The highest court also overturned this judgment. In the view of the defence, a third appeal is not possible for reasons of time: the Cavagnolo case becomes time-barred in April 2025.
This marks the third consecutive time that the highest court has overturned a second-instance conviction – in addition to the two Cavagnolo decisions, the Naples proceedings (February 2025).
For context: a Turin court had previously reached the opposite conclusion on the same death. In its judgment of 4 November 2015, the court of first instance in Turin (Tribunale di Torino) acquitted four former local managers of the plant, including in the case of this worker. According to the court’s findings, fibre exposure at the plant had fallen sharply from the mid-1970s onwards thanks to technical improvements; it could not be proven that the later, considerably lower exposure had contributed to the illness. The worker concerned had worked in asbestos processing since the 1950s – some twenty years before the period attributed to Stephan Schmidheiny began.
Current status: The Turin Court of Appeal will hear the case on 3 December 2026. In the view of the defence, the case has been time-barred since April 2025. The defence is seeking an acquittal on the merits; at the very least, the proceedings must be discontinued as time-barred.
20 February 2025
Italy’s highest court overturns conviction in the Eternit proceedings concerning Naples
Second reversal of a conviction of Stephan Schmidheiny within one year – the case returns to Naples for retrial.
On 19 February 2025, the Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Italy’s highest court, overturned Stephan Schmidheiny’s second-instance conviction in the Eternit bis proceedings concerning the former Eternit factory in Napoli Bagnoli and remanded the case to the Naples Court of Appeal for retrial. In June 2024, the Court of Appeal had sentenced Stephan Schmidheiny to three years and six months’ imprisonment for the negligent homicide of a former worker.
This is the second time within one year that the highest court has overturned a conviction of Stephan Schmidheiny. In May 2024, it had already annulled the conviction in the proceedings concerning the Cavagnolo factory because the lower court had not soundly established the individual causal link.
The proceedings began in 2019 as a prosecution for the intentional homicide of eight people – six former employees and two local residents. In April 2022, the first-instance assize court ruled out intent, acquitted Stephan Schmidheiny in one case and discontinued six cases as time-barred. He was convicted solely of the negligent homicide of one former worker, who had worked at the plant from 1954 to 1985 – more than twenty years of that time before the period from June 1976 attributed to Stephan Schmidheiny.
The defence states: a criminal conviction requires proof that the conduct of a specific person caused the death of a specific individual. In the view of the defence, where asbestos exposure extended over decades and came from multiple sources, such proof cannot be furnished to the standards of criminal law. It expects the courts in Naples, as well as in the Casale Monferrato proceedings, to apply these standards.
Stephan Schmidheiny has faced criminal proceedings in Italy for some twenty years. They concern the period from 1976 to 1986, during which the Swiss Eternit Group was the principal shareholder of the Italian company Eternit SpA. Asbestos processing was legal at the time; Italy did not ban it until 1992. Stephan Schmidheiny was never a member of the board of directors or the management of Eternit SpA. During this period, the Swiss Eternit Group, as shareholder, provided the company with more than 80 billion lire, a substantial part of which went to occupational safety and emission reduction. Since 2008, Stephan Schmidheiny has also voluntarily offered compensation to former employees and local residents suffering from asbestos-related diseases.
Current status: The written reasoning was filed on 17 April 2025 (Judgment No. 15220/2025). The highest court held that the lower court had not been entitled to infer from the duration and intensity of exposure that the course of the disease had been accelerated in the specific case, and called for case-specific evidence. In the resumed proceedings, the Naples Court of Appeal heard the prosecution’s medical expert on 23 June 2026. At the hearing on 8 October 2026, the Public Prosecutor requested that the proceedings be discontinued as time-barred; the defence is seeking discontinuation on the grounds of ne bis in idem or, in the alternative, an acquittal on the merits. On 27 October 2026, the Naples Court of Appeal discontinued the proceedings as time-barred; a criminal conviction is thus ruled out. The defence is appealing the judgment to the Court of Cassation and is seeking an acquittal on the merits (see release of 27 October 2026).
10 May 2024
Italy’s highest court overturns conviction in the Eternit proceedings concerning Cavagnolo
First reversal of a conviction of Stephan Schmidheiny in the Eternit bis proceedings – the case returns to the Turin Court of Appeal.
On 9 May 2024, the Corte Suprema di Cassazione, Italy’s highest court, overturned Stephan Schmidheiny’s second-instance conviction in the Eternit bis proceedings concerning the former Eternit factory in Cavagnolo (Piedmont) and remanded the case to the Turin Court of Appeal for retrial. In February 2023, the Court of Appeal had sentenced Stephan Schmidheiny to a suspended prison term of one year and eight months for the negligent homicide of a former worker. It had acquitted him of the charge of negligent homicide of a person living near the plant.
The Cavagnolo plant closed in 1982. The deceased worker had been employed there since 1955, more than twenty years before the period from June 1976 attributed to Stephan Schmidheiny. In 2015, a Turin court had reached the opposite conclusion on the same death: the court of first instance acquitted former local managers of the plant because it could not be proven that the later, considerably lower exposure had contributed to the illness.
With this decision, the highest court has for the first time overturned a conviction of Stephan Schmidheiny in the Eternit bis proceedings. The defence expects the Turin Court of Appeal, as well as the courts in the Naples and Casale Monferrato proceedings, to apply the standard of individual causation consistently: a criminal conviction requires proof that the conduct of a specific person caused the death of a specific individual.
Stephan Schmidheiny has faced criminal proceedings in Italy for some twenty years. They concern the period from 1976 to 1986, during which the Swiss Eternit Group was the principal shareholder of the Italian company Eternit SpA. Asbestos processing was legal at the time; Italy did not ban it until 1992. Stephan Schmidheiny was never a member of the board of directors or the management of Eternit SpA. Since 2008, he has voluntarily offered compensation to former employees and local residents suffering from asbestos-related diseases.
Current status: The written reasoning was filed on 25 July 2024 (Judgment No. 30615/2024). The highest court found fault with the reasoning on the causal link. The Turin Court of Appeal convicted Stephan Schmidheiny again in December 2024; the highest court also overturned this judgment in March 2025 (see release of 22 March 2025).